“They are grabbing Nicole. They are pulling her off the train.”
“They are kicking us all off the train. We haven’t done anything.”
“What are you doing? You can’t just kick us off for being Black.”
But they did.
Two Railway Patrol Officers boarded a train at Cockburn Central Station, south of Perth. They followed up a complaint from a passenger who had called TransPerth off their mobile.
Without any evidence other than a complaint from one party, eight individuals – four adults, four young children (two of them toddlers) – were bundled off the train. But of course they’re Black, this is some sort of par for the course. Therefore in insularly racist Western Australia where prejudices and stereotypes do the rounds daily, being Black is enough for various authorities to cast aspersion. It is as if they have some sort of immunity to do so. Western Australia is mud thick deep in racism. Sadly, many Western Australians do not see their racism. They can call someone a ‘lazy coon’, or ‘a good for nothing Gin’, or ‘loud Black bastard’ and ditto with certain migrant groups referring to them ‘as money grubby wogs’ and ‘reffo bastards’ while still carrying on with hand on heart that they are not racist. Being of colour myself, and having lived in Western Australia for two decades, I felt the burning racism of this State from when I first arrived.
The more west you go across this continent the worse it gets for First Peoples. It is worst in Western Australia. All the statistics demonstrate this – the homelessness rates, the extensiveness of acute poverty, the arrest rates, the imprisonment rates, the suicide rates. In Western Australia one in 13 of all Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander adult males are in jail. Where else in the world do you get this sort of horror statistic? In general there are about 30,000 move-on notices by police each year in Western Australia with about 10,000 of these move-on notices dished out to First Peoples – but First Peoples are only less than 3 per cent of the State’s population. There are only 80,000 people who identify as Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander in Western Australia – but 10,000 move-on notices are somehow dished out to them in the one year. Go figure?
The Aboriginal Legal Services does not have the resources to defend every single victim of racism – or every poor soul who is arrested. Hence many are railroaded into jail. The Aboriginal Legal Services of Western Australia and its long-serving CEO, Dennis Eggington have long despaired of the State’s racism. But 10,000 move-on notices! This is in addition to the catastrophic statistics – nearly 2,500 of their adults are in one of the State’s 14 prisons, more than 2,000 of their children have been removed from their families by the State. Another couple of thousand sleep rough, in addition to the uncountable itinerant population, and in addition to the tens of thousands who are dished out extreme poverty. But Western Australia is this nation’s most affluent jurisdiction, with the world’s highest median wages. Standalone, the WA economy would be larger than the economies of 140 countries.
Today, a score of well-respected Noongars converged on an Anglican Cathedral in the heart of Perth’s commercial district where possibly the remains of one of their resistance fighters, Midgegooroo, the father of Yagan, have been uncovered in various earthworks. Midgegooroo was executed by the colonialists four years into the invasive colony – in 1833. His son, Yagan would be murdered months later. Well known Noongar rights advocate, law student, Marianne Mackay and four of her young children spent the day alongside Elders outside the Anglican Cathedral. The Elders, such as Albert Corunna, are the direct descendants of Midgegooroo and Yagan. Ms Mackay may not be a direct descendant but she is nevertheless related to Midgegooroo and similarly so of the other Noongars murdered by colonialists and buried unceremoniously at the site. At the end of their vigil Ms Mackay, her children and her companions boarded a train south bound. To reach their destination they changed trains at Murdoch Station.
“This is where it all began,” said Ms Mackay.
“We had been talking about the day. We had been talking about Midgegooroo and our frustration that the earthworks were not halted. We were talking about this being desecration and that they should cordon off the area and respect that many of our ancestors are buried there. They should have initiated careful exploratory work.”
They got on the homeward bound train, with a pram, four children. Two of the adults were carrying their flags, rolled up.
“We got these dirty gestures and looks. We live with that sort of behaviour.”
“One lady gave us the finger. I couldn’t believe it.”
“I shouldn’t have been surprised but well I want to think better of people because there are really good White people too,” said Ms Mackay.
“Then there started some of the racist comments, the usual stuff, in line with the get over the invasion stuff.”
“I am one to talk to people and I tried to talk to them, talk to them about our peoples, what we have been through, what we go through but it didn’t resonate. We just got more garbage hurled back at us.”
“You’d think they’d have some honour you know, with my kids with me, but you know we get put down all the time.”
“But we have to be strong, stay strong, so the children grow up strong.”
But people should know better. Here is another young generation being dished out that being Black is a liability; that they are targeted. This racialism is racism. Yet you will have people swear that they are not racist. Racism has many veils and layers. Railway Patrol Officers boarded the train at Cockburn Central and who following up what I believe to be a malicious phone call sought out Ms Mackay and her companions. Here, I have to declare an impartiality conflict of interest because I heard part of what was happening on the train and I must state that I found the conduct of the Patrol Officers deplorable. I had asked Ms Mackay to not end the phone call, so I could hear what was happening.
I asked to speak to the Officers. They refused.
Ms Mackay said, “I asked them why they were targeting us? I asked them what is it that we are supposed to have done. They came back with the obnoxious argument that we were being ‘loud’. Someone phoned them and complained about us being ‘loud’. The train guards would not listen to anything we had to say.”
I have contacted TransPerth and discussed what occurred and suggested that it does not appear that the Officers had any reasonable ground to eject anyone off the train – not the White passengers, not the racists, not Ms Mackay, not her four children, nor her three companions. The conduct of the Officers was more than just discriminatory, it was racist, no question. They can argue it otherwise, and obviously they will but I can state what it was. I have seen it in every layer of society in Western Australia. It must be said, fearlessly, and chased down. It was racism. I have lived racism since I was born; I know when it occurs. My academic research has studied racism but with a focus on the ways forward. The Officers should have deescalated the situation but they did not. Instead four young children had a taste of racism Western Australian style. And till things change in this far too often redneck State, they will taste a lot more of it.
But there were two young White men on that train who did not want to have a bar of the racism and who stood up to be counted. As the Railway Patrol Officers were forcibly removing one of Ms Mackay’s companions from the train – Nicole Culbong – the two young men jumped up from their seats and told the Officers that they were wrong in their assumptions. They stated Ms Mackay’s party had not done anything to justify their ejection from the train. One of them was allegedly pushed back and both were told by one of the Officers to “stay out of this”.
However they would later file complaints to TransPerth. Good on them. There should more Western Australians like them. In time there will be.
The Officers will now have to rely on the gamble that the CCTV footage will show some misbehaviour by Ms Mackay and her party so in some way to justify their racist judgment call. The Officers and TransPerth can argue all they like to about “zero tolerance” and “safety” but this is all bullshit. There was no violence or any threat of violence. There was no threatening disorderly conduct. There was some racism from some White passengers. There was a discussion by Ms Mackay and Ms Culbong about what her people continue to endure. The Officers should be ashamed. But even more ashamed should be the passenger who nicked in a complaint to TransPerth. More ashamed should be the passenger who kicked off the racism with her deplorable gesture to Ms Mackay and company. But you know it happens all the time. Racism has been normalised in Western Australia despite vilification laws and the boundless tokenisms.
I decided to drive from inner city Perth to Cockburn Central to pick up Ms Mackay and her children and deliver them to the sanctity of their home. As I exited the freeway and onto Beeliar Drive I remembered this part of southern Perth was Midgegooroo’s Country. Beeliar Drive is named after his Country – Beeliar. Then I remembered that it was right where Cockburn Central now stands that Midgegooroo was apprehended by the colonialist invaders. He was jailed at a grubby barrack where now the Anglican deanery stands in the heart of Perth’s commercial district. On May 22, 1833 he was murdered by a firing squad – no trial. Not that he could speak the Queen’s English… As I turned right off Beeliar Drive into the street that would lead me to Ms Mackay on this hot sweltering day, I noticed the street had been renamed Midgegooroo Drive. I and Ms Mackay would consider this both a remarkable coincidence and eerie.
– The Stringer will publish TransPerth’s response once we receive it.
Im a white person living in Melbourne. To all the white offending people on that train God made man equal. You should be ashamed. To any Aboriginal Person coming to Melbourne you have accommodation at my home for free and this includes all the Aboriginal People on this train, sorry this invitation is not extended to any white person harbouring a hatred towards any Aboriginal Person for any unjust reason. Pearl Green
Good on you Pearl. I’m ashamed to be Australian.
Yamajee Elder Albert Corrunna is not Noongar he is from Canarvon he is a Yamajee not Noongar and not related to Yagan at all,so please do not include bullshit in your otherwise true story. [Peter, Albert said he is a direct descendant and so do many others state this of Albert, however we have allowed your comment. You need to take this up with Albert, not us – The Stringer’s Editors]. And Elder Richard Wilks is from Leonora, both these Elders were brought up at Sister Kates Orphanage as Noongars in Noongar Country. [Peter, similarly you need to take this up with Richard. As far we know he is a direct descendant and he states this – The Stringer’s Editors]. And married into a traditional Noongar family groups.
Kevin Miller and his very extended family are the Direct descendents of the Yagan and Midgegooroo and Yellagonga family of Noongar Leaders and traditional owners of the Swan Valley….before known as King Billy Beliar country and the Beliar River. Which is now known as Perth and the Swan River.I know the whole history of all Noongar Families that are traditional owners, remember I fought for Native Title in Federal Court for the Noongar Land Council from 2000 to 2006. Six years in Federal Court where all evidence was examined in the Single Noongar Claim, which we won adjudicated finally by Justice Wilcox of the Federal Court. in Perth.Peter David.CEO of The Noongar Land Council.An Unpaid servant for the NOONGAR ELDERS and Traditional owners of Western Australia.
Well done all for reporting this appalling TransPerth, publicly paid, “professional” bullying behaviour. Clearly HM’s responsible WA Government’s Transport Minister & Shadow also need to be actively made aware along with Kwinana MLA & Shadow Health Minister Roger Cook. I will copy & paste into an email to Roger now.
This is one of the reasons I do not take public transport. I have witnessed far too much of this and have had enough. I am white and respect all people but I have witnessed on lots of occasions other white or light coloured people goading the first people and trying to get them frustrated or angry. This happens all the time and sometimes I intervene but always get attacked for it and have to get of the transport too. I have read and studied the first peoples histories and I think it deplorable and we should now be doing our best to understand where they are coming from and respect their history and also give them all the help we can to make their lives especially the young ones the best thet we can. This was their counry no matter what tony Abbott says it always was and we should be grateful that we get to enjoy it.
It’s about time all the history books were rewritten to educate everyone about what really happened when so called terra nullis was taken over by war, murder and slavery and all that went with it
I feel sorry for this group of people trying to tell their story to a bunch deaf eared racistsand if anyone deserves the finger it’s the idiot that gave it!
Terrible situation, there needs to be inquiry into how and why the registered Aboriginal site 29278 being that of Midgegooroo’s burial may have been uncovered. Were TO’s consulted ? why no section 18. The Anglican Church would be better to engage properly under the law. What “lessons learnt from violent colonial past.”
Thank you for this excellent piece, Gerry. And for your kind actions in helping the people concerned. I am disgusted by what happened. Thankfully, at least some people stood up to what was happening. I wish I had been there.
Transperth should carry out a full unbiased, honest investigation.
They are with witnesses and video footage to show the blatant lies told by these women!!!
Disgusting. I’d be quite happy if Western Australia seceded and became Boganland. If you are Koori, if you are Muslim, if you are gay, if you are an intellectual, if you are a socialist. WA doesn’t want you. But WA wants the bloated capitalists like BIGGYBIG PIGGYWIG GINA.
Perhaps we could dig a ditch and separate WA from Oz. We could call it the Great Trench of Decency.
Well said Peter David,
I am Kevin Miller ‘s grandson, It is sad to see that even though he has been formally noticed as the True descendent of Yagan and Midgegooroo people still aren’t respecting it. If it was anyone else there names would of been on the front page of the West Australian.
Family files complaint: http://nirs.org.au/NEWS/Family-files-complaint-after-being-unfairly-kicked-off-public-transport
This is the most fictious article I’ve read.. I was on that train. I heard and saw all that occured and you’re so call innocenjt Mrs Mackay and her friends started yelling at everyone. Called everyone rednecks (deleted by The Stringer) brained washed white people. THEY WERE THE ONES SWEARING AT EVERYONE with their kids watching. (Statement deleted by The Stringer) I had the gall to say ‘I have Aboriginal family and its people like you that give our people a bad name’!!!!.. A proud and wonderful culture and heritage tarnished by stupid and irresponsible, loud mouthed, foul mouth women, who had their children with them. (Statement deleted by The Stringer) I know those officers will have nothing to answer for, as they did NOTHING WRONG. Its articles like this that breed racism!!.. (Statement deleted by The Stringer)
[Preface deleted] Kevin miller is the true descendants of Yagan 1of December 2014 last year order by justice judge barker